Tad R. Callister: The Book of Mormon Translation

Play video

In Sunday’s afternoon conference session, Elder Tad R. Callister directly addressed so many critical claims.  Watch the talk here.

Critics’ Claims fall short.  Very short.  

Claim ONE:  Joseph was a creative genius at 23.

Image result for creative genius

Critics now say this.  But nobody thought Joseph was a genius from 1820 – 1844.  Instead, they laughed at his “obvious” fraud.

Image result for unique names and places

100s of unique names, places, and details.  Where’d all that creativity originate?  Critics now claim Joseph used numerous books and materials.  Not a single person reported seeing Joseph with such.  Indeed, scribes, including Emma explained Joseph lacked notes or manuscript upon which to rely. And Emma further noted that Joseph couldn’t have concealed such if he had tried.

In fact, Joseph dictated page after detailed, interwoven, harmonious page with his head in a dark hat, looking at a seer stone.  

Image result for LDS joseph smith rock hat

If he used the mountain of books (for which there is no evidence) as critics claim, how did he sift through it all, winnow out the irrelevant, and keep the intricate facts straight?  He dictated 500+ pages fluidly.  

Image result for photographic memory

To pull this scheme off, Joseph must have also had a photographic memory of prodigious proportions. But critics don’t seem to have ever made that claim in his day.

The above only accounts for the book’s historical content.

 

Image result for theological genius

Claim TWO:  Joseph was a theological genius at 23.

Again, critics say this now, though they didn’t in his lifetime.

Think of what the Book of Mormon contains.  Its teachings clarify and contradict Christian teachings of his time.  Joseph wrote that the Fall was a positive step forward.  Nobody claims that.  His dictation described the covenants of baptism.  Rich doctrinal insights into the Atonment and Resurrection.  Sermon on faith in Alma 32.  Allegory of the Olive Tree.

Image result for book of mormon olive tree allegory

All of this was off the top of his head with no notes?  Not possible.  Instead, God’s fingerprints are all over this book.

Image result for genius

Why didn’t anyone else say all of this in the last 1800 years?  “Geniuses” have lived and died.  It wasn’t genius.  It was revelation.

 

Claim THREE:  Joseph was a naturally gifted writer at 23.

Joseph Interweaved names, places, strategies, coined phrases that are now on refrigerator doors, etc.   These are messages that live, breathe, and inspire.

Image result for when ye are in the service of your fellow beings

Joseph dictated the entire work in 65 working days.  With only (mostly) minor grammatical corrections after that.  No working draft.  

Emma disagreed with this claim.  Emma says Joseph couldn’t write a coherent letter.  Elder Nelson made 40 drafts of a recent conference talk.  Precision take work.  And time.  Lots of time.

 

What of Joseph’s other claims?

Golden plates?  LOL!  Everyone knew in Joseph’s day that papyrus and parchment was what the ancients wrote on!  Unrelenting criticism was heaped upon Joseph. Now experts know metal records exist elsewhere.

Image result for metal plates with writing

Use of cement!  Another LOL.  Till cement structures were found in ancient America.  Lucky guesser, Joseph!  

Image result for cement in ancient america

In spite of all the odds, Joseph guessed right over and over and over?  Sure.   

None of this — guessing-right-consistently hypothesis — makes sense.    Further, all 11 witnesses remained true.

The Book of Mormon is an inspiration.

 

From John Welch:  “Hours Never to be Forgotten: Timing the Book of Mormon Translation”

Book of Mormon Translation, Manuscripts, Original Text, and Textual Variants

Play video

Tad R. Callister delivered a masterpiece on 10/1/17 about Joseph’s translation process.  Joseph was neither a creative nor theological genius.  He was an inspired prophet!

Watch Elder Callister’s talk here.

 

Watch this video about the 2 manuscripts:  1) the dictated or original manuscript and 2) the printer’s manuscript.

Watch this about the preservation of the printer’s manuscript by David Whitmer:

 

LDS Truth Claims insight:

Royal Skousen in his 2003 Book of Mormon Archaeological Forum Presentation.

Book of Mormon textual changes

Summary: The claim is often heard that there are more than 4000 changes to the Book of Mormon text. The majority of these are typographical. Few of the changes are significant. We examine the more noteworthy changes.

JUMP TO SUBTOPIC:

 

John Hall’s 2007 FAIR speech:  “The Problem with Tampering with the Word of God:  As far as it is translated correctly.”